The Worst Pokémon Games (and why)

MandJTV

This video has been trending in United Kingdom, United States, Canada, and Papua New Guinea

In the world of Pokémon gaming, controversies are as common as Pikachu sightings in Viridian Forest. Fans debate tirelessly over which games stand out as the best, and which fall flat faster than a Magikarp flopping on dry land. But amidst the ongoing chatter, one video has stirred the pot like never before. Titled 'The Worst Pokémon Games (and why),' this video dives deep into the murky waters of Pokémon brilliance, only to emerge with a scathing verdict: Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl have earned the dubious honor of being crowned the worst mainline games ever released.

The video's narrator, a seasoned Pokémon player with a penchant for critique, pulls no punches as he lays out his case. While he admits to enjoying previous Pokémon titles despite their flaws, he reserves a special level of disdain for the Gen 4 remakes, Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl. In a blistering takedown, he unpacks the reasons why these games have failed to capture his Poke-passion.

One of the main arguments presented in the video revolves around the issue of improvement—or lack thereof. The narrator makes it clear that while older Pokémon games like Red and Blue may have their own flaws, Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl missed the mark by failing to build upon the advancements made in subsequent generations. Quality of life improvements such as the physical-special split, character customization, and the removal of HM moves are cited as key areas where the Gen 4 remakes fall short.

Furthermore, the video delves into the regional Pokédex, a sore point for many players when it comes to Diamond and Pearl. The narrator highlights the limited selection of Pokémon available in the regional dex, pointing out the imbalance in type distribution and the frustrating post-game locks on certain evolutions. The decision to restrict access to new evolutions until late in the game is criticized as a major misstep, robbing players of the chance to experience these fresh additions to the roster.

But perhaps the most contentious argument put forth in the video is the comparison to Platinum version, the oft-overlooked gem in the Gen 4 trilogy. The narrator laments the missed opportunity to incorporate Platinum's improvements into Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, particularly in addressing the regional dex issues. While Platinum expanded the dex to include a wider range of Pokémon, the remakes chose to stick faithfully to the original Diamond and Pearl dex, much to the disappointment of fans seeking a more robust gameplay experience.

In closing, the video leaves no doubt that Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl have fallen short of expectations, failing to live up to the legacy of their predecessors or the potential for improvement that was within reach. It's a harsh indictment of two games that were meant to be a nostalgic return to the Sinnoh region, but instead have left a bitter taste in the mouths of many Pokémon fans.

As the debate rages on in the Pokémon community, one thing is clear: the video titled 'The Worst Pokémon Games (and why)' has sparked a fiery discussion that shows no signs of cooling down. Whether you agree with the narrator's scathing critique or not, one thing is certain—Pokémon gaming will always be a realm where passion and criticism walk hand in hand, ready to battle it out like a pair of fierce Pokémon trainers in a heated gym showdown

Share Video

¿Do you like The Worst Pokémon Games (and why)? Share it with your people...

Playlist